Showing posts with label democracy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label democracy. Show all posts

Tuesday, November 11, 2008

Tactical Media, but Whose Tactics?

Axel Bruns argues that citizen journalism (or tactical media) holds a new and important place in the mediasphere, opening up a space for discussion with traditional mainstream media. He says blogs and other forms of this tactical media "have added a second tier of news media that comments on, critiques, and regularly corrects the mainstream news . . ." This has led to journalism as a conversation, rather than as a lecture, Bruns says.

However, he discounts political antagonisms as holding any place in this new form of journalism: "a true 'rule of the people' can only be established through productive debate and deliberation; it cannot be reached through entrenched political antagonism," Bruns writes. Are productive debate and deliberation not precisely a product of antagonism, though? Bruns pinpoints it himself, albeit unknowingly, when he says "sites which do little more than publish content are in danger of becoming mere PR tools for oppositional groups, simply containing press releases for the latest cause."

Bruns also misses a crucial element of this conversation. While he does say that "each time news bloggers and other citizen journalists point to omissions, misrepresentations, or biases in the mainstream media content by contrasting news stories, press releases, and other background information, they use the news media's own tools and resources against it." On the other side of this, however, is that mainstream media sources are also quite adept at taking tactical media stories and recontextualizing them to fit the way that traditional media is covering any given story.

So, while Bruns contends (and he quotes Douglas Rushkoff here) that "'we are heading not towards a toppling of the democratic, parliamentary or legislative processes, but towards their reinvention in a new, participatory context,'" I would ask how this is possible without antagonism. It seems to me that without antagonism, we wind up with simple echo chambers in which no real change occurs.

Tuesday, October 28, 2008

Technological Fetishism and Online Democracy

Professor Dean writes in the Digital Media and Democracy book that we now have a system of communicative capitalism. She says that instead of being heard, messages are "circulated, reduced to the medium." This reduction results in part from a technological fetishism. We believe that now, more than ever, technology and online contribution equate to democracy and democratic values. Part of this is something (which she mentions in the article and I've mentioned in a previous post) that Slavoj Zizek calls interpassivity. We allow the technological object to act (democratically) for us, and while we feel that we've "done our part," no change actually occurs.

This is backed up, in part, by Clay Shirky's essay, "Power Laws, Weblogs, and Inequality." In it he says that only a few blogs today are read widely, while a huge number fly under the radar and are rarely visited, regardless of whether or not they have a valuable contribution to make to any number of discussions.

Professor Dean says that "to ontologize the political is to collapse the very symbolic space necessary for politicization, a space between an object and its representation, its ability to stand for something other than itself." This destruction of the symbolic removes real hope for political action online, and is simultaneously happening in other regions of our society as well. In the consumer realm, the symbolic has all but disappeared - instead of actual political action, we buy "fair trade" coffee and invest in products which are political for us. Likewise, "by sending an email, signing a petition, responding to an article on a blog, people can feel political."

All hope is not lost, however. While thought like this seems to indicate that any entry onto the web should come with the disclaimer "abandon all hope, etc etc," it does not mean that things cannot change. If we can stop the fetish surrounding technology and break away from the idea that passively "acting" online is akin to political action, then real political action becomes a reality once again. As Professor Dean puts it, "politics in the sense of working to change current conditions may well require breaking with and through the fantasies attaching us to communicative capitalism."

Thursday, October 2, 2008

Deliberation or De-Liberation?

There is a certain sense of optimism permeating the readings for today in Rebooting Democracy. Much the literature is concerned with how to make the internet, blogs and "echo chambers" work in such a way to increase the democratic potential of the medium.

I hesitate to be so optimistic, however. The democratic potential of the internet is there, to be sure, but it rests on control being in the hands of the people. So far, that has not been the case. While D. Travers Scott, in "Tempests of the Blogosphere," from Digital Media and Democracy says that blogflops can be attributed to a lack of a sense of storytelling, is that really all there is at play? He says that "Communicative agency, expanded through technology, allows more individuals to better join the mediated public sphere and thereby participate in civic deliberation." The question, then, becomes how to define deliberation.

While David Weinberger, in "Echo Chambers = Democracy," says that echo chambers actually increase deliberation and reasoned discussion, Scott notes that "participation in the mere proliferation of messages is by no means necessarily engaging others in antagonistic, productive, political debate." It may be true that most people will not put their ethics aside to sit down and have a reasoned conversation with those who hold diametrically opposed viewpoints, this does not mean that the answer is to continue this trend online. Perhaps the answer, instead, is to encourage exactly the kind of reasoned discussion that Weinberger discounts as unrealistic. If we believe that our representative democracy works because of deliberation, it makes very little sense to say that real deliberation is impractical.

The liberation of online discussion and the "freedom" it offers - is this real or perceived? Are we simply substituting passive participation online for actual participation in politics? Is our liberty to have a hand in how our government works gaining ground - or is the ground itself crumbling?