David Weinberger describes, in his discussion of hyperlinks, connections that can serve to reconfigure the entire (business) world. But do these connections actually reduce the distance between people, enabling better and more human conversations? Or do they serve to more distinctly define our place as nodes in networks?
He says that within pyramidal structures we are strictly defined. But it would seem that even in the decentralized power structure the web provides, we are still just as (if not more) defined than ever before - this definition is simply disguised as something we have written ourselves. We believe these new definitions to be our very essence, that the web captures something not previously able to be tamed. Weinberger obviously believes this makes us more free, but we are still defined - instead of a hierarchical definition of where we fit into a power structure, we have a definition bounded by hyperlinks.
Weinberger also talks about the freedom of movement on the web, saying, "If you want to go to a page, you just click on the link and, boom, you're there. (The fact that this might have required, beneath the surface, thirty 'hops' among servers in places you've never heard of is completely irrelevant. You don't see the hops; you just see the page)." But if we remember the digital enclosure, then we know that these thirty hops are not "completely irrelevant." Even if we don't see them, those other thirty servers do see them - and it makes their definition of us ever clearer.
Finally, Weinberger also introduces a concept we saw in Wark's Gamer Theory. "The Web isn't primarily a medium for information, marketing, or sales. It's a world in which people meet, talk, build, fight, love, and play," Weinberger says. He goes on to note that "without play, only Shit Happens. With play, Serendipity Happens." Play, however, is spontaneous. It cannot be given to us - in Wark's terms, it would seem that only a designer can truly play. If this is true, then Weinberger is probably right, and play would be good for a business. The problem, however, is that neither the pyramidal structure he derides nor the decentralized hyperlinked one he promotes actually provide much of a space for play.
Showing posts with label freedom. Show all posts
Showing posts with label freedom. Show all posts
Thursday, December 4, 2008
Tuesday, September 30, 2008
Bourgeois Apathy
Felix Stalder, in Bourgeois Anarchism, says that it is cheaper and easier than ever to communicate across time and space with individuals and groups. Every step of this communication is carried out by algorithms that create and store a record of it - what Andrejevic termed the digital enclosure. One of the dangers inherent with this is that it vastly increases the surveillance capacities of large (and, I would add, small) organizations such as the state or private corporations that bid on surveillance work.
Freedom-oriented groups in the '60s provided an "artistic critique" of capitalism, says Stalder, but this was co-opted into the current "creative industry" - anyone can be an artist online. It has lost it's revolutionary edge to the point that it is barely recognized that it ever had one.
In much the same way, small networked organizations have arisen today and have the ability, in Stalder's view, to challenge the state. Although he does talk about the privatization of security and surveillance, Stalder fails to see how even these small organizations can be co-opted to prevent any potential for real change. He even goes so far as to say that the "liberal democracy" we have and its civil society, is being weakened by these small groups. What he doesn't say is how this is not a threat to the state - but a means to the end we've been on the road to since at least the Great Depression, the New Deal and the massive expansion of executive power that came with it.
Freedom-oriented groups in the '60s provided an "artistic critique" of capitalism, says Stalder, but this was co-opted into the current "creative industry" - anyone can be an artist online. It has lost it's revolutionary edge to the point that it is barely recognized that it ever had one.
In much the same way, small networked organizations have arisen today and have the ability, in Stalder's view, to challenge the state. Although he does talk about the privatization of security and surveillance, Stalder fails to see how even these small organizations can be co-opted to prevent any potential for real change. He even goes so far as to say that the "liberal democracy" we have and its civil society, is being weakened by these small groups. What he doesn't say is how this is not a threat to the state - but a means to the end we've been on the road to since at least the Great Depression, the New Deal and the massive expansion of executive power that came with it.
Thursday, September 11, 2008
I blog, therefore I
The blog platform (and, for that matter, the structure of the web itself) allows for a certain amount of freedom, both for the blogger and the reader(s). The question becomes how much freedom particular bloggers or websites want to allow.
I wonder if Mill's concept of freedom of speech/the press still holds in an arena like the internet. He was a proponent of allowing all in a society to express their ideas, no matter how extreme or deviant. Mill believed that only when all ideas were out in the open could the truth of each be tested against the others, making space for the "best" of them to wade their way through criticism and emerge victorious (best for whom, is what I want to know). Anyway, Mill preceded blogs by a pretty substantial period of time, so I digress . . .
In a New York Times article The Trolls Among Us, Mattathias Schwartz writes, "Today the Internet . . . is a mass medium for defining who we are to ourselves and others." If this is true, do users get to pick a) who they are defined as and b) who they are defined to? The first questions seems like the answer should be painfully obvious: you are who you define yourself as. In a space full of "trolls," however, this truth becomes less absolute. Instead, there is the possibility that I could be defined by anonymous strangers/hackers who may or may not have the same sense of ethics and morals I do. I could, of course, block them from viewing my blog/Facebook/whatever - as Professor Dean says she did to Bill White (Bad Subjects: Blogging Theory), but this is literally no obstacle when all a troll has to do is create another identity (or several more, you know, just in case) to continue harassing whomever they please.
The second question has no obvious answer, and is even more unsettling because of this. In the age of the Internet, we have little to no control over who can see our information - or how it is used. Some may be as harmless as marketers who simply want to know what we like, so that they can better shape products to our preferences (or shape our preferences to their products - I often wonder how much of this already happens on the Internet, which is to say, how many pop-ups, flashy banner ads and corporate websites have I seen, and what part they have played in the creation of my online consumer-persona). On the other hand, how would we feel about the government having complete access to all of our most personal information hidden away in "secret" files on our computers, or being able to keep tabs on every word we write to friends on AIM? If this information is never used, the illusion of privacy persists.
I wonder if Mill's concept of freedom of speech/the press still holds in an arena like the internet. He was a proponent of allowing all in a society to express their ideas, no matter how extreme or deviant. Mill believed that only when all ideas were out in the open could the truth of each be tested against the others, making space for the "best" of them to wade their way through criticism and emerge victorious (best for whom, is what I want to know). Anyway, Mill preceded blogs by a pretty substantial period of time, so I digress . . .
In a New York Times article The Trolls Among Us, Mattathias Schwartz writes, "Today the Internet . . . is a mass medium for defining who we are to ourselves and others." If this is true, do users get to pick a) who they are defined as and b) who they are defined to? The first questions seems like the answer should be painfully obvious: you are who you define yourself as. In a space full of "trolls," however, this truth becomes less absolute. Instead, there is the possibility that I could be defined by anonymous strangers/hackers who may or may not have the same sense of ethics and morals I do. I could, of course, block them from viewing my blog/Facebook/whatever - as Professor Dean says she did to Bill White (Bad Subjects: Blogging Theory), but this is literally no obstacle when all a troll has to do is create another identity (or several more, you know, just in case) to continue harassing whomever they please.
The second question has no obvious answer, and is even more unsettling because of this. In the age of the Internet, we have little to no control over who can see our information - or how it is used. Some may be as harmless as marketers who simply want to know what we like, so that they can better shape products to our preferences (or shape our preferences to their products - I often wonder how much of this already happens on the Internet, which is to say, how many pop-ups, flashy banner ads and corporate websites have I seen, and what part they have played in the creation of my online consumer-persona). On the other hand, how would we feel about the government having complete access to all of our most personal information hidden away in "secret" files on our computers, or being able to keep tabs on every word we write to friends on AIM? If this information is never used, the illusion of privacy persists.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)